{
 "symbol": "ZEC", "name": "Zcash", "review_date": "2026-10-08",
 "reviewer": "AI", "model_id": "claude-fable-5-1", "logic_version": "value_v1", "prompt_sha256": "58434c62f807c2035cf603f7f93e6e22db880e9f4172968767efef7d1f326065",
 "one_sentence_zh": "Zcash 是零知识证明驱动的隐私支付链，用户为屏蔽交易付矿工费，持有 ZEC 的理由是把它当作可私密转移的数字货币；区块奖励 80% 给矿工、12% 进协议级 Lockbox、8% 给社区资助。",
 "one_sentence_en": "Zcash is a zk-proof privacy payments chain; users pay miner fees for shielded transactions and hold ZEC as privately transferable digital money; block subsidy goes 80% to miners, 12% to a protocol-level Lockbox and 8% to community grants.",
 "red_lines": {
   "R1": {"hit": false, "note": "链上手续费与区块奖励可核，但协议没有「收入」概念，持币人收入为 0 属结构性而非不可核实。", "sources": ["https://zips.z.cash/zip-1015"]},
   "R2": {"hit": false, "note": "无回购/销毁计划。", "sources": ["https://zips.z.cash/zip-1015"]},
   "R3": {"hit": false, "unlock_12m_frac_of_circ": 0.0, "note": "PoW 发行，无团队/投资人锁仓；2024-11 第二次减半后每块 1.5625 ZEC，ECC/ZF 的协议内分配地址已移除，12% 进入无支取机制的 Lockbox。", "sources": ["https://zips.z.cash/zip-1015", "https://zcashbrazil.substack.com/p/zcash-shielded-news-vol7"]},
   "R4": {"hit": false, "note": "ZEC 是货币型资产（支付 gas、作为价值载体），不是积分；不带治理投票权。", "sources": ["https://zips.z.cash/zip-1015"]},
   "R5": {"hit": false, "note": "一句话可说清：隐私货币，用户付矿工费。", "sources": ["https://zodl.com/zodl-raises-25m-in-seed-funding/"]},
   "R6": {"hit": false, "note": "2026 年初 ECC 与母公司 Bootstrap 治理纠纷导致 CEO 及全部工程/产品团队离开，另立 ZODL 并获 $25M 种子轮（Paradigm、a16z、Coinbase Ventures 等），开发并未中断，不构成跑路。搜索摘要提到 2026-07 Ironwood/NU6.3 因 Orchard 池伪造漏洞更换资金池，原文未打开、是否有损失未核实，列为待核。", "sources": ["https://whale-alert.io/stories/d8940196b1f9ea/Josh-Swiharts-Zcash-Open-Development-Lab-raises-25M-seed-to-continue-Zcash-protocol-work-and-expand-Zodl-shielded-wallet", "https://zodl.com/zodl-raises-25m-in-seed-funding/"]}
 },
 "A_judge": {"mechanism_executing": false, "mechanism_desc": "没有把收入回到代币的机制：交易费归矿工；12% 区块奖励进入 Lockbox 但 ZIP 1015 明确「当前无支取机制」，待社区决定去中心化分配方式。", "sources": ["https://zips.z.cash/zip-1015"]},
 "B": {
   "one_sentence": {"score": 2.5, "evidence": "隐私货币定位清晰：Zodl（原 Zashi）钱包推动屏蔽池活动增长 400%+，2025-10 以来完成 $600M+ ZEC 兑换；付费方是需要私密转账的用户。", "sources": ["https://zodl.com/zodl-raises-25m-in-seed-funding/"]},
   "moat": {"score": 1.5, "evidence": "护城河是品牌与密码学研发积累（zk 领域最早的生产级实现），2026 年顶级 VC 集体注资 ZODL 表明开发者/资本生态在变宽；但 Monero 及各链隐私层竞争，网络效应中等。", "sources": ["https://zodl.com/zodl-raises-25m-in-seed-funding/", "https://whale-alert.io/stories/d8940196b1f9ea/Josh-Swiharts-Zcash-Open-Development-Lab-raises-25M-seed-to-continue-Zcash-protocol-work-and-expand-Zodl-shielded-wallet"]},
   "ten_years": {"score": 1.5, "evidence": "存续理由：隐私是加密货币原教旨需求，减半后发行递减、四年期资助模型已定；若 Zcash 消失，可用的强隐私 L1 选项会明显减少。扣分因监管对隐私币的持续压力与 PoS 转型未完成。", "sources": ["https://zips.z.cash/zip-1015", "https://zcashbrazil.substack.com/p/zcash-shielded-news-vol7"]},
   "people_governance": {"score": 1.0, "evidence": "正面：NU6 取消 ECC/ZF 直接拨款、改为 Lockbox + ZCG 五人委员会，透明度提升；ZODL 获强投资人背书。负面：ECC/Bootstrap 分裂导致开发组织割裂、Lockbox 积累但无支取规则、治理无代币投票而靠社区咨询小组。", "sources": ["https://zips.z.cash/zip-1015", "https://whale-alert.io/stories/d8940196b1f9ea/Josh-Swiharts-Zcash-Open-Development-Lab-raises-25M-seed-to-continue-Zcash-protocol-work-and-expand-Zodl-shielded-wallet"]}
 },
 "C_judge": {
   "users_growth": {"score": 1.0, "evidence": "无 90 天活跃地址对比；代理指标：Zodl 钱包使屏蔽池活动自 2024 年以来增长 400%+、2025-10 至 2026-03 完成 $600M+ 兑换，方向为正但非近 90 天口径。", "sources": ["https://zodl.com/zodl-raises-25m-in-seed-funding/"]},
   "utility": {"score": 0.75, "evidence": "持有 ZEC 本身就是用途（私密价值转移），屏蔽交易必须用 ZEC 支付费用。", "sources": ["https://zodl.com/zodl-raises-25m-in-seed-funding/"]},
   "culture": {"score": 0.5, "evidence": "2026 年隐私叙事升温、Zodl 移动钱包评分 4.9/4.66（2024 年底数据），但未找到年轻人/社媒增速数据。", "sources": ["https://zcashbrazil.substack.com/p/zcash-shielded-news-vol7"]},
   "web3_direction": {"score": 0.5, "evidence": "隐私是 web3 长期方向之一，但 Zcash 作为独立 L1 与「隐私作为各链功能层」的趋势有张力。", "sources": ["https://zodl.com/zodl-raises-25m-in-seed-funding/"]}
 },
 "confidence": "low",
 "notes": "ZEC 市值 $22.6B 是本组最大，但 A 维机制为空（Lockbox 无支取）。Orchard 伪造漏洞与 Ironwood 升级只在搜索摘要中出现，未能打开原文，R6 暂不命中但必须补核：若存在未赔付的伪造铸币损失则应改判。ZEC 没有治理代币属性，B4 评分基于组织治理而非代币治理。"
}
