{
 "symbol": "ZAMA", "name": "Zama", "review_date": "2026-10-08",
 "reviewer": "AI", "model_id": "claude-fable-5-1", "logic_version": "value_v1", "prompt_sha256": "58434c62f807c2035cf603f7f93e6e22db880e9f4172968767efef7d1f326065",
 "one_sentence_zh": "Zama 是全同态加密（FHE）保密计算协议，dApp 为加密/解密/协处理服务以 ZAMA（按美元计价）付费且 100% 销毁，运营者与质押者靠每年约 5% 的增发获酬；代币 2026-02 上线，目前未找到任何可核的付费用量。",
 "one_sentence_en": "Zama is an FHE confidential-compute protocol: dApps pay ZAMA (USD-priced) for encryption/decryption/coprocessing with 100% of fees burned, while operators and stakers are paid from ~5% annual emissions; the token launched Feb 2026 and no verifiable paid usage was found.",
 "red_lines": {
   "R1": {"hit": true, "note": "未找到任何可核实的协议费用或销毁数据（无链上看板、无 DefiLlama 适配器、项目博文未披露用量）；主网状态来源互相矛盾（Phemex 称 2025-12-30 上线，Substack 称目标 2026 Q4）。", "sources": ["https://www.zama.org/post/zama-token-launch", "https://phemex.com/academy/what-is-zama", "https://asymmetricjump.substack.com/p/zama-zama-https-for-blockchains"]},
   "R2": {"hit": false, "note": "无回购；设计为费用 100% 销毁，但未找到实际销毁记录。", "sources": ["https://www.zama.org/post/zama-token-launch"]},
   "R3": {"hit": true, "unlock_12m_frac_of_circ": 0.6, "note": "估算值。流通约 25.5 亿（23%）；VC 20% + 天使 10% 为 12 个月 cliff、cliff 时解锁 1/10、其后 24 个月线性；团队 20% 为 12 个月 cliff 后 48 个月线性。2027-02-02 投资人+内部人 cliff 单次解锁即约等于当前市值的 19.2%，加上 2027-03~10 的线性部分（投资人约 1.24 亿/月、团队约 4,600 万/月），12 个月团队/投资人解锁估算 ≈ 15~17 亿 ≈ 流通 60%+，远超 25%。", "sources": ["https://app.tokenomics.com/tokenomics/zama/unlocks", "https://tokenomist.ai/zama/tokenomics"]},
   "R4": {"hit": false, "note": "ZAMA 用于支付协议费、质押与治理。", "sources": ["https://www.zama.org/post/zama-token-launch", "https://asymmetricjump.substack.com/p/zama-zama-https-for-blockchains"]},
   "R5": {"hit": false, "note": "一句话可说清，见 one_sentence。", "sources": ["https://asymmetricjump.substack.com/p/zama-zama-https-for-blockchains"]},
   "R6": {"hit": false, "note": "未找到被盗/下架/跑路证据。", "sources": ["https://phemex.com/academy/what-is-zama"]}
 },
 "A_judge": {"mechanism_executing": null, "mechanism_desc": "机制为'费用 100% 销毁 + 增发奖励运营者/质押者'，官方博文有明文，但未找到任何链上销毁金额或费用看板，无法确认是否在执行。", "sources": ["https://www.zama.org/post/zama-token-launch", "https://phemex.com/academy/what-is-zama"]},
 "B": {
   "one_sentence": {"score": 2.0, "evidence": "谁付钱（需要保密计算的 dApp）、为什么付（链上隐私）说得清，但付费是否已发生未找到证据。", "sources": ["https://asymmetricjump.substack.com/p/zama-zama-https-for-blockchains"]},
   "moat": {"score": 1.0, "evidence": "技术领先与品牌：FHE 原创团队，Pantera（约 $10 亿估值轮）、Metaplanet 参投，公开拍卖募 $1.18 亿、超额 218%；但无审计公开、运营者集中，尚无网络效应。", "sources": ["https://asymmetricjump.substack.com/p/zama-zama-https-for-blockchains", "https://phemex.com/academy/what-is-zama"]},
   "ten_years": {"score": 1.0, "evidence": "链上保密计算是长期需求，FHE 若可规模化则不可替代；但执行复杂度高、未通过生产验证。", "sources": ["https://asymmetricjump.substack.com/p/zama-zama-https-for-blockchains"]},
   "people_governance": {"score": 0.5, "evidence": "无历史兑现记录可查；基金会 32% 为最大份额（2026-11-02 单次解锁 1.146 亿全部归基金会），投资人/团队 cliff 将于 2027-02 开启，治理尚未去中心化。", "sources": ["https://app.tokenomics.com/tokenomics/zama/unlocks", "https://tokenomist.ai/zama/tokenomics"]}
 },
 "C_judge": {
   "users_growth": {"score": 0.0, "evidence": "未找到证据（无活跃地址/用量数据）。", "sources": []},
   "utility": {"score": 0.5, "evidence": "协议费必须以 ZAMA 支付、运营者必须质押 ZAMA——设计上刚需，但实际用量未核到。", "sources": ["https://www.zama.org/post/zama-token-launch"]},
   "culture": {"score": 0.2, "evidence": "拍卖超额认购显示投机热度，未找到社区/创作者采用证据。", "sources": ["https://phemex.com/academy/what-is-zama"]},
   "web3_direction": {"score": 0.8, "evidence": "链上隐私/保密计算是 web3 的关键缺口之一（'HTTPS for blockchains'）。", "sources": ["https://asymmetricjump.substack.com/p/zama-zama-https-for-blockchains"]}
 },
 "confidence": "low",
 "notes": "R3 比例为按两家解锁站的归属规则推算，非站点直接给出的 12 个月汇总；即使只取 2027-02-02 单次 cliff（19.2% 市值），加上后续 8 个月线性也稳超 25%。R1 命中是因为找不到任何费用/销毁证据而非发现造假。tokenomist 与 app.tokenomics 的分组口径不同（Team/VC/Angels/Treasury vs Foundation/Private/Insiders）。"
}
