{
 "symbol": "SOLV",
 "name": "Solv Protocol",
 "review_date": "2026-10-08",
 "reviewer": "AI",
 "model_id": "claude-opus-5-5",
 "logic_version": "value_v1",
 "prompt_sha256": "58434c62f807c2035cf603f7f93e6e22db880e9f4172968767efef7d1f326065",
 "one_sentence_zh": "Solv Protocol 是 BTC 收益平台：BTC 持有人存入换取 SolvBTC/xSolvBTC 并进入收益金库，Solv 从金库收益中抽绩效费及申购/赎回费；SOLV 代币目前只有治理与期权价值，不分享这些现金流。",
 "one_sentence_en": "Solv Protocol is a Bitcoin yield platform: BTC holders deposit to mint SolvBTC/xSolvBTC and enter yield vaults, and Solv takes performance, subscription and redemption fees on that yield; the SOLV token currently carries governance and optionality only, with no claim on that cash flow.",
 "red_lines": {
  "R1": {
   "hit": false,
   "note": "收入有第三方统计（Alea 研究：2025-Q4 年化协议收入约 $29M，来源主要为金库绩效费，Trading Vault 50% 绩效费为最大项），DefiLlama 有费用/收入数据，Chainlink 储备证明 2025-09 上线。但需警惕：2025-01 被指 TVL 重复计算（自称 2.5 万 BTC，据称 DefiLlama 人员核实约 1.06 万 BTC），且 Trading Vault 部分策略在链下，收入可复算程度有限。不判命中但降低置信度。",
   "sources": [
    "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025",
    "https://rekt.news/bad-math-homework"
   ]
  },
  "R2": {
   "hit": false,
   "note": "未发现回购/销毁（Tokenomist 显示无回购数据，Alea 明确 SOLV 尚不通过回购/分红获得现金流）。",
   "sources": [
    "https://tokenomist.ai/solv-protocol/buyback",
    "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025"
   ]
  },
  "R3": {
   "hit": true,
   "unlock_12m_frac_of_circ": 0.28,
   "note": "Tokenomics.com：下一次 2026-10-17 解锁约 1.897 亿 SOLV，其中私募投资人 53.3% + 内部人 16.0% 约 69%（约 1.31 亿）；归属期至 2028-12，按此月度份额外推未来 12 个月约 15.8 亿 SOLV，对流通 57.15 亿约 27.6%，≥25% 命中。私募 25.10% + 团队顾问 11.30% 共 36.4% 总量，1 年悬崖已于 2026-02 结束。外推有误差，拿不准往严判。",
   "sources": [
    "https://app.tokenomics.com/tokenomics/solv-protocol/unlocks",
    "https://tokenomist.ai/solv-protocol",
    "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025"
   ]
  },
  "R4": {
   "hit": false,
   "note": "SOLV 是治理代币（Solv DAO），承载治理权；无经济权。",
   "sources": [
    "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025"
   ]
  },
  "R5": {
   "hit": false,
   "note": "一句话可说清：BTC 收益金库，收益抽成。",
   "sources": [
    "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025"
   ]
  },
  "R6": {
   "hit": false,
   "note": "2026-03-03 BRO 金库双重铸币漏洞被盗 38.05 SolvBTC（约 $2.7M），影响不足 10 名用户，Solv 承诺全额承担损失，属已处置事件。",
   "sources": [
    "https://www.theblock.co/post/392492/solv-protocol-says-exploit-drained-2-7-million-from-bitcoin-yield-vault"
   ]
  }
 },
 "A_judge": {
  "mechanism_executing": false,
  "mechanism_desc": "无回购/销毁/分红/质押分配；Alea 研究原文意为 SOLV 尚未通过回购或分红获得这部分现金流，估值反映的是治理与期权。DefiLlama 持币人收入 $0 与此一致。",
  "sources": [
   "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025",
   "https://tokenomist.ai/solv-protocol/buyback"
  ]
 },
 "B": {
  "one_sentence": {
   "score": 2.0,
   "evidence": "“BTC 持有人存 BTC 拿收益，Solv 抽收益分成”清楚；扣分因为代币不分享现金流。",
   "sources": [
    "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025"
   ]
  },
  "moat": {
   "score": 1.0,
   "evidence": "BTCFi 先发者之一，2025-Q4 TVL 约 $1.24B、SolvBTC 供应约 1.02 万 BTC、50+ 合作方；但 BTC LST/包装赛道竞品多、切换成本低，收入高度依赖单一 Trading Vault。",
   "sources": [
    "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025"
   ]
  },
  "ten_years": {
   "score": 1.0,
   "evidence": "BTC 生息需求长期存在，但 Solv 不可替代无证据；若消失，用户可转向其他 BTC 包装/收益产品，行业不倒退。",
   "sources": [
    "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025"
   ]
  },
  "people_governance": {
   "score": 0.5,
   "evidence": "投资人+团队占 36.4% 总量且自 2026-02 起每月大额释放；2025-01 TVL 夸大争议时联创回应“This. Is. War.”，储备证明拖到 2025-09 才上线；正面是 2026-03 漏洞损失由项目承担。",
   "sources": [
    "https://app.tokenomics.com/tokenomics/solv-protocol/unlocks",
    "https://rekt.news/bad-math-homework",
    "https://www.theblock.co/post/392492/solv-protocol-says-exploit-drained-2-7-million-from-bitcoin-yield-vault",
    "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025"
   ]
  }
 },
 "C_judge": {
  "users_growth": {
   "score": 0,
   "evidence": "未找到近 90 天活跃地址数据；金库用户 5000+（2025-Q4），2025-Q4 年化收入较 Q3 下降 11%，无增长证据，给 0。",
   "sources": [
    "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025"
   ]
  },
  "utility": {
   "score": 0.25,
   "evidence": "使用 SolvBTC 与金库不需要持有 SOLV，仅治理用途。",
   "sources": [
    "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025"
   ]
  },
  "culture": {
   "score": 0.25,
   "evidence": "Binance Megadrop 占 6.09% 份额带来散户分发，但无社媒/社区增速数据。",
   "sources": [
    "https://tokenomist.ai/solv-protocol"
   ]
  },
  "web3_direction": {
   "score": 0.5,
   "evidence": "BTC 原生资产进入 DeFi（BTCFi）是 web3 方向之一，但链下签名/托管成分削弱去中心化程度。",
   "sources": [
    "https://alearesearch.io/reports/benchmark/solv-q4-2025",
    "https://rekt.news/bad-math-homework"
   ]
  }
 },
 "confidence": "medium",
 "notes": "DefiLlama 映射核对：派单把 SOLV 映射到 DefiLlama 的 SolvBTC，SolvBTC 是 Solv 主产品，但 Solv Protocol 在 DefiLlama 另有母协议页（solv-protocol，含金库等其他产品），母协议口径的费用/收入应更完整；两页本次均 403 未能打开，无法逐项对比，建议量化层改用母协议口径。无论哪种口径，持币人收入都为 0。R3 比例为按 10-17 单次解锁份额外推的估算。"
}