{
 "symbol": "AAVE", "name": "Aave", "review_date": "2026-10-08",
 "reviewer": "AI", "model_id": "claude-fable-5-1", "logic_version": "value_v1", "prompt_sha256": "58434c62f807c2035cf603f7f93e6e22db880e9f4172968767efef7d1f326065",
 "one_sentence_zh": "Aave 是最大的链上借贷协议，借款人付利息、被清算者付清算罚金、GHO 借款人付铸造费，协议抽成进 DAO 国库，并自 2025-04 起用国库收入在二级市场回购 AAVE（2026-06-27 起改为不可变的自动化回购）。",
 "one_sentence_en": "Aave is the largest on-chain lending protocol; borrowers pay interest, liquidated users pay penalties and GHO minters pay fees, the protocol's cut goes to the DAO treasury, which has bought back AAVE on secondary markets since April 2025 (automated and immutable since 27 June 2026).",
 "red_lines": {
   "R1": {"hit": false, "note": "收入链上可查且 DAO 有公开报表：2026 年 1-2 月借款费 $13.7M + 清算费 $8.96M；派单 DefiLlama 30d 费用 $37.6M / 协议收入 $4.9M。", "sources": ["https://governance.aave.com/t/aave-dao-funding-insights/24192"]},
   "R2": {"hit": false, "note": "回购资金来自协议收入与国库稳定币（国库持 >$50M 稳定币），2025-04-09 至 2026-02-28 投入 $42M 买入 205K AAVE；Aavenomics 3.0 把协议/GHO 收入直接路由给回购，不是卖币或增发。", "sources": ["https://governance.aave.com/t/aave-dao-funding-insights/24192", "https://whale-alert.io/stories/88c701030d2153/Aave-launches-Aavenomics-30-activating-automated-AAVE-buybacks-and-reducing-DAO-spending"]},
   "R3": {"hit": false, "unlock_12m_frac_of_circ": 0.0, "note": "Tokenomist 标注 ‘fully unlocked’：流通 15.44M / 总量 16M，剩余 564K 为生态储备无解锁表；无团队/投资人锁仓。", "sources": ["https://tokenomist.ai/aave"]},
   "R4": {"hit": false, "note": "AAVE 有治理权（DAO 投票决定回购、预算）与经济权（回购、stkAAVE 安全模块质押 3.69% APR、Umbrella）。", "sources": ["https://governance.aave.com/t/aave-dao-funding-insights/24192"]},
   "R5": {"hit": false, "note": "一句话可说清：借贷协议，借款人付利息。", "sources": ["https://governance.aave.com/t/aave-dao-funding-insights/24192"]},
   "R6": {"hit": false, "note": "未发现未处置重大事件；2026 年治理持续推进 Aavenomics 3.0。", "sources": ["https://thedefiant.io/news/defi/aave-confirms-aavenomics-3-0-live-buybacks-dao-spending-cut"]}
 },
 "A_judge": {"mechanism_executing": true, "mechanism_desc": "两阶段：①Aavenomics Part One（2025-04 起）由 Aave Finance Committee 每周 $250K~$1.75M 二级市场回购，截至 2026-02-28 买入 205K AAVE（$42M，占总量 1.28%），年度额度拟由 $50M 降至 $30M；②Aavenomics 3.0 于 2026-06-27 上线，改为不可变、非自由裁量的自动回购，所有协议/GHO/品牌产品收入进 DAO 国库后自动执行。另有 stkAAVE 每日 260 AAVE 质押奖励（拟降至 220）。注意：派单 DefiLlama ‘持币人收入 30d = $0’ 与上述执行证据不符，疑为 DefiLlama 适配器口径未纳入回购；本次 DefiLlama 页面 403 未能核对。", "sources": ["https://governance.aave.com/t/aave-dao-funding-insights/24192", "https://whale-alert.io/stories/88c701030d2153/Aave-launches-Aavenomics-30-activating-automated-AAVE-buybacks-and-reducing-DAO-spending", "https://thedefiant.io/news/defi/aave-confirms-aavenomics-3-0-live-buybacks-dao-spending-cut"]},
 "B": {
   "one_sentence": {"score": 2.5, "evidence": "借贷协议：借款人付利息、清算付罚金、GHO 付铸造费，付费动机（杠杆/流动性）清楚。", "sources": ["https://governance.aave.com/t/aave-dao-funding-insights/24192"]},
   "moat": {"score": 2.0, "evidence": "流动性深度 + 品牌/集成生态（V2/V3/V4 多链、GHO、Umbrella、Aave App/Pro），借贷协议存款越多利率越好的网络效应明显；DAO 国库 >$100M 非 AAVE 资产。扣分：Morpho/Spark 等模块化借贷在蚕食份额，且 DAO 年支出预算 $164M 偏高。", "sources": ["https://governance.aave.com/t/aave-dao-funding-insights/24192"]},
   "ten_years": {"score": 2.0, "evidence": "运行 6 年、经历多次市场崩盘无坏账事故，是 DeFi 借贷事实标准；若消失链上借贷流动性与可组合性会明显倒退。", "sources": ["https://governance.aave.com/t/aave-dao-funding-insights/24192"]},
   "people_governance": {"score": 2.0, "evidence": "承诺兑现率高：2024 年中提出的 Aavenomics 路线图在 2026-06 完成；回购按周公开执行并有 DAO 财务透明报告；未发现团队持续卖币。扣分：治理实际由 ACI/Aave Labs 等少数服务商主导，Ahab 增长预算 $75M 等大额支出。", "sources": ["https://governance.aave.com/t/aave-dao-funding-insights/24192", "https://thedefiant.io/news/defi/aave-confirms-aavenomics-3-0-live-buybacks-dao-spending-cut"]}
 },
 "C_judge": {
   "users_growth": {"score": 1.0, "evidence": "未找到近 90 天 vs 前 90 天活跃地址数据；只有收入口径：2026 年 1-2 月累计 ~$23M 协议收入，方向未知，保守给中等偏低分。", "sources": ["https://governance.aave.com/t/aave-dao-funding-insights/24192"]},
   "utility": {"score": 0.5, "evidence": "借贷不需要持有 AAVE；AAVE 的需求来自治理、stkAAVE/Umbrella 质押承保与回购吸筹。", "sources": ["https://governance.aave.com/t/aave-dao-funding-insights/24192"]},
   "culture": {"score": 0.5, "evidence": "DeFi 蓝筹，开发者与机构采用强，但对年轻散户文化吸引力一般；无社媒增速数据。", "sources": ["https://thedefiant.io/news/defi/aave-confirms-aavenomics-3-0-live-buybacks-dao-spending-cut"]},
   "web3_direction": {"score": 1.0, "evidence": "无许可借贷 + 收入自动回流代币（Aavenomics 3.0 不可变合约）是 web3 代币经济的方向性范例。", "sources": ["https://whale-alert.io/stories/88c701030d2153/Aave-launches-Aavenomics-30-activating-automated-AAVE-buybacks-and-reducing-DAO-spending"]}
 },
 "confidence": "medium",
 "notes": "DefiLlama 页面 403 未能打开，派单‘持币人收入 30d=$0’与治理论坛公开的回购执行记录（$42M 买入 205K AAVE）矛盾，程序按 DefiLlama 算 A 分时会低估，建议人工用链上回购地址重算。Aavenomics 3.0 上线后的具体回购金额本次未找到链上明细。"
}
